| NJCAA All-Americans | Year | Sport |
| David Cochran | 1977 | Men’s Basketball |
| Cindy Young | 1978 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Cindy Young | 1979 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Tom Henke | 1979 | Men’s Baseball |
| Karla Swoboda | 1983 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Tom Bildner | 1983 | Men’s Basketball |
| Beth Thater | 1983 | Women’s Basketball |
| Tony Dye | 1984 | Men’s Basketball |
| Dan Dohogne | 1989 | Men’s Basketball |
| Erin Dickinson | 1989 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Erin Dickinson | 1990 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Anne Brinker | 1990 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Pete Kinsey | 1990 | Men’s Soccer |
| Christi Evans | 1993 | Women’s Basketball |
| Karen Dolan | 1998 | Women’s Basketball |
| Omir Santos | 2000 | Men’s Baseball |
| Wesley Louissaint | 2003 | Men’s Soccer |
| Mauricio Pena | 2004 | Men’s Soccer |
| Seymour Williams | 2007 | Men’s Soccer |
| Nickardo Blake | 2008 | Men’s Soccer |
| Nickardo Blake | 2009 | Men’s Soccer |
| Erica LaBoube | 2008 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Kasey Kirchhofer | 2009 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Kasey Kirchhofer | 2010 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Tiffany Borgerding | 2011 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Darren Hamilton | 2015 | Men’s Soccer |
| Shelby Friend | 2016 | Women’s Softball |
| Mackenzy Vedder | 2016 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Jacob Moore | 2016 | Men’s Soccer |
| Magnus Andersen | 2017 | Men’s Soccer |
| Arman Kovac | 2019 | Men’s Soccer |
| NJCAA Academic All-Americans | Year | Sport |
| Jill Van Leer | 1988 | Women’s Basketball |
| Laurie Duemler | 1989 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Blake Marquart | 1991 | Men’s Basketball |
| Barb Jany | 1992 | Women’s Basketball |
| Devin Kirby | 1999 | Men’s Basketball |
| Domen Zadravec | 1999 | Men’s Basketball |
| Kristen Hassler | 2000 | Women’s Softball |
| Kelly Lansford | 2000 | Women’s Softball |
| Bryan Meyer | 2000 | Men’s Basketball |
| Kristin Highley | 2006 | Women’s Softball |
| Kari Blankenship | 2008 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Anne Jacquin | 2008 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Luis Percovich | 2010 | Men’s Soccer |
| Jill Griffin | 2010 | Women’s Softball |
| Kasilda Miller | 2011 | Women’s Softball |
| Edwin Meza | 2011 | Men’s Soccer |
| Lacey Lackmann | 2011 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Brooke Brenton | 2011 | Women’s Softball |
| Mary Engemann | 2011 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Cody Beck | 2012 | Men’s Soccer |
| Sarah Braun | 2012 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Lauren Dudgeon | 2012 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Erica Mitchell | 2012 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Brian Monge | 2012 | Men’s Soccer |
| Sarah Schwentker | 2012 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Sarah Gilkerson | 2012 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Julie Scheer | 2013 | Women’s Sofball |
| Amber Odom | 2013 | Women’s Softball |
| Sadie Pafford | 2013 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Andrew Hamerlinck | 2014 | Men’s Soccer |
| Hannah Leslie | 2014 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Kaytlyn Wells | 2014 | Women’s Softball |
| Alyssa Schrader | 2015 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Kierstin Monzyk | 2015 | Women’s Softball |
| Paige Schmelzle | 2015 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Dayla Gruenloh | 2015 | Women’s Softball |
| Karissa Hoffman | 2015 | Women’s Softball |
| Kayla Borcherding | 2016 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Sarah Borgerding | 2016 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Chelsea Delay | 2016 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Virgina Ward | 2016 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Monica Kelley | 2016 | Women’s Softball |
| Kayla Kelly | 2016 | Women’s Softball |
| Zeke Little | 2016 | Men’s Soccer |
| Umoh Ufot | 2016 | Men’s Soccer |
| Dayla Gruenloh | 2016 | Women’s Softball |
| Karissa Hoffman | 2016 | Women’s Softball |
| Taylor Davis | 2016 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Eden Henry | 2016 | Women’s Softball |
| Sarah Borgerding | 2017 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Monica Kelley | 2017 | Women’s Softball |
| Ashley Blanton | 2017 | Women’s Softball |
| Andrei Ciot | 2017 | Men’s Soccer |
| Skylar Evans | 2017 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Eden Henry | 2017 | Women’s Softball |
| Chukwujindu Isreal- Bolarinwa | 2017 | Men’s Soccer |
| Umoh Ufot | 2017 | Men’s Soccer |
| Samanatha White | 2017 | Women’s Softball |
| Alayna Abney | 2017 | Women’s Softball |
| Magnus Andersen | 2017 | Men’s Soccer |
| Connor Bandre | 2017 | Men’s Soccer |
| Kayla Borcherding | 2017 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Archibald Darko-Boateng | 2017 | Men’s Soccer |
| Jensen Crenshaw | 2017 | Women’s Softball |
| Grace Goedde | 2017 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Jacob Moore | 2017 | Men’s Soccer |
| Makayla Schumann | 2017 | Women’s Softball |
| Mackenzy Vedder | 2017 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Alyana Abney | 2018 | Women’s Softball |
| Magnus Andersen | 2018 | Men’s Soccer |
| Jessica Kelly | 2018 | Women’s Volleyball |
| McKenzie Struckhoff | 2018 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Jensen Crenshaw | 2018 | Women’s Softball |
| Kori Fiedler | 2018 | Women’s Softball |
| Lydia Klenke | 2018 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Ashley Miller | 2018 | Women’s Softball |
| Allison Skaggs | 2018 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Samanatha White | 2018 | Women’s Softball |
| Marissa Boyd | 2018 | Women’s Softball |
| Taylor Ruth | 2018 | Women’s Softball |
| Amber Struemph | 2018 | Women’s Softball |
| Jordyn Vrba | 2018 | Women’s Softball |
| Marissa Boyd | 2019 | Women’s Softball |
| Mallory Feldewerth | 2019 | Women’s Softball |
| Kori Fiedler | 2019 | Women’s Softball |
| Seeley Friend | 2019 | Women’s Softball |
| Arman Kovac | 2019 | Men’s Soccer |
| Katelyn Gaus | 2019 | Women’s Softball |
| Lauren Grunwaldt | 2019 | Women’s Softball |
| Alyssa Moore | 2019 | Women’s Softball |
| Kaley Roper | 2019 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Nicole Roper | 2019 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Kayla Schmidt | 2019 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Leonard Sowa | 2019 | Men’s Soccer |
| Samantha Staab | 2019 | Women’s Volleyball |
| Billy Thompson | 2019 | Men’s Soccer |